Here’s a bold prediction that might just divide Steelers Nation: Colin Cowherd is at it again, suggesting the Pittsburgh Steelers trade a whopping six draft picks to land Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson. Yes, you read that right—six picks. But here’s where it gets controversial: Cowherd believes this move could redefine the Steelers’ future in a post-Mike Tomlin era. After their Wild Card loss to the Houston Texans and Tomlin’s unexpected departure, the Steelers are at a crossroads. And Cowherd thinks Simpson is the answer—even if it means parting with a significant chunk of their 12 picks in the 2026 NFL Draft.
On his Fox Sports Radio and FS1 show, Cowherd didn’t hold back: ‘If you’re Pittsburgh with all these picks, my takeaway is you give out about six of them to go get Ty Simpson in the first round. Say what you want, it’s something!’ But is it really ‘something,’ or is Cowherd stretching too far? After all, this isn’t the first time he’s proposed a head-scratching trade for the Steelers. Remember when he suggested they trade T.J. Watt, George Pickens, and two first-round picks for Shedeur Sanders? Pittsburgh passed on that idea—and on Sanders three times in the draft—allowing him to fall to the Cleveland Browns at No. 144.
And this is the part most people miss: Cowherd’s proposals aren’t just about the players; they’re about sparking a reset. With Tomlin gone and Aaron Rodgers potentially on the move, the Steelers are entering uncharted territory. Cowherd’s latest idea? Trade the house for Simpson, a quarterback whose draft projections range from top-10 to late first round. But here’s the kicker: If the Steelers truly want Simpson, they likely wouldn’t need to give up six picks—unless Cowherd knows something we don’t.
Is Cowherd a visionary or just a provocateur? His track record with the Steelers is mixed, but his willingness to think outside the box is undeniable. Imagine the Steelers actually pulling the trigger on this trade—it would be a statement move, for better or worse. But let’s not forget: Cowherd’s proposals often spark more debate than action. So, is Ty Simpson worth six picks? And more importantly, should the Steelers trust Cowherd’s advice this time around?
Here’s a thought-provoking question for you: If you were the Steelers’ GM, would you take Cowherd’s gamble on Simpson? Or would you play it safe and keep your draft capital? Let’s hear your take in the comments—this is one debate that’s sure to heat up!
